Skip to content

Added an empty repo as a submodule (debugging)

These troubleshooting steps from GPT-4o helped me to debug a submodule error related to accidentally cloning a repo before it had anything in it.

How this happened:

  • Created repo B (repository holding documentation on a topic) directly on Github
  • Forgot to clone it to my local
  • Added repo B as a submodule to repo A
  • Git doesn't like this: why do we have a commit-less repo in our submodule index? This makes no sense!
  • Resolution:

  • Clear out the submodule files

  • Remove them from gitmodules
  • Clone and push from repo B so that it's not empty and has a commit history
  • Now start again: add and initiate repo B as a submodule, commit (repo A), and push

GPT 4o Instructions

The error message you are encountering, "error: 'site-base/docs/repos/notepads/ideas/' does not have a commit checked out. fatal: adding files failed", typically occurs when you are trying to add files to a directory that is part of a Git submodule or contains a separate .git folder.

Here are the most common causes and solutions for this issue:

1. Submodule Issue

If the directory you are working with (site-base/docs/repos/notepads/ideas/) is part of a Git submodule, this error can occur if the submodule has not been properly initialized or updated.

Solution:

  • Run the following commands to initialize and update the submodule:
    git submodule init
    git submodule update
    
  • After this, try adding your files again:
    git add <file>
    

2. Directory Contains Its Own .git Folder

Another possibility is that the directory (site-base/docs/repos/notepads/ideas/) contains its own .git folder, making it a separate Git repository. Git does not allow adding files from one repository into another unless handled as a submodule.

Solution:

  • Check if there is a .git folder inside the problematic directory:
    ls -la site-base/docs/repos/notepads/ideas/
    
  • If you find a .git folder, you can either:
  • Remove the .git folder if it's not needed:
    rm -rf site-base/docs/repos/notepads/ideas/.git
    
  • Or, if it is meant to be a submodule, ensure it is correctly configured as one.

3. Detached HEAD State

If the repository or submodule is in a detached HEAD state, meaning no branch is currently checked out, Git will not allow adding new files until you are on a valid branch.

Solution:

  • Check out a branch in the main repository or in the submodule (if applicable):
    git checkout main
    

4. General Git Troubleshooting

If none of the above solutions work, try these general troubleshooting steps: - Ensure you are on an active branch and not in a detached HEAD state. - Run git status to check for any other issues. - If you suspect file permission issues, ensure that your user has the correct permissions to modify the files and directories.

By following these steps, you should be able to resolve the issue and successfully add your files to Git .